PicoSearch
 

The content and the accuracy of web sites and articles quoted and/or referred to on our pages are the responsibility of their respective authors. By including them here, Good News for Israel does not indicate agreement with any particular point of view nor do we validate any facts presented.
Our purpose is to promote iniformed dialog by providing articles and web links that present some of the viewpoints.
It is for the visitor to decide their validity for himself or herself.
Where applicable,
 © copyright 2003
Good News for Israel,
6408 Minnetonka Blvd
St Louis Park, MN 55426
Phone: (952) 926-7369, E-mail: gnfi@gnfi.org
 or Contact Webmaster

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, any copyrighted work in this web site is archived here under fair use without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in the site’s information for personal and/or for non-profit research & educational purposes.
Click for Reference
 
Main Issues

The controversy surrounding Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ is a complex set of interlocking issues - not all of them are openly expressed. We have identified six of them below.

Just click on the subject title to go to our summary of the issue as well as to a listing of related articles and web links by others.

The main issues addressed on this site are presented very well by Peter J. Boyer in his article quoted from below. We highly recommend that you click on the title and read the whole article.

ANTI-SEMITISM (and the Holocaust)

THE GOSPELS & THE NEW TESTAMENT
(also, the movie’s non-nonbiblical sources)

MEL GIBSON (the believing Traditionalist Catholic and director)

POLITICS & THE PEOPLE OF GOD (A short historical overview of the theological reasons on why some Christians persecuted Jews.)

ROMAN CATHOLICISM (and Vatican II)

WARRIOR JESUS (the “historical Jesus” and who He is not)

The Passion of the Christ: A film by Mel Gibson and Icon Productions. The Passion of the Christ is a vivid depiction of the last 12 hours of Jesus Christ's life with James Caviezel and Monica Bellucci. Click on the graphic above to go to the movie trailer, or click here to go to an unofficial web site supporting the film. Click herer to go to ICON ENTERTAINMENT’s official web site.

The Jesus War, Mel Gibson’s Obsession, by Peter J. Boyer
(emphasis added)

The dark screen filled with the printed words of prophesy from the Old Testament Book of Isaiah, written four hundred years before Christ: “He was wounded for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities. By his stripes we are healed.”

There was, in the two hours that followed, much wounding and crushing, and, when the lights came back up, there was some wiping away of tears. I found the film riveting and quite disturbing, and I was struck by an insistent memory from a Jesus movie from my childhood, George Stevens's “The Greatest Story Ever Told.” In the final scene, the risen Jesus, wispily played by Max Von Sydow in a pageboy haircut, levitates in the clouds as a heavenly choir sings the “Hallelujah Chorus.”

Gibson had undertaken “The Passion of the Christ” with the avowed purpose of contravening the overwrought piety of such conventions, and in that, certainly, he had succeeded. Gibson's resurrected Christ rises in the tomb with a steely glare, and then strides purposefully into the light, to the insistent beat of martial drums. With that, Gibson's Passion story, and perhaps even, the controversy that has attended it, became clear. Gibson had once said that he wasn't interested in making a religious movie, and in “The Passion of the Christ” he hadn't. He was making a war movie.

Gibson's story line reflects the basic Christian narrative of Christ's Passion, as it is laid out collectively in the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Jesus of Nazareth is a Jewish carpenter in Roman-controlled Palestine, who preaches a message of love and forgiveness, with an increasingly messianic subtext. During the Passover season, he enters the Holy City of Jerusalem, where he is welcomed by adoring crowds who hail him as the long-promised Messiah, bringing deliverance and a new kingdom. But Jesus is considered dangerous by the Jewish high priests, who conspire to arrest and try him, and then deliver him to the Roman prefect Pilate for execution, on the ground of treason against Rome. Jesus knows that his fate is the Cross, and briefly wishes to avoid it (“Oh, my Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me”); but he also knows that God, his father, sent him into the world for the very purpose of dying, as a sacrifice for the redemption of all mankind.

script for “The Passion of the Christ” was the New Testament, and that the film was directed by the Holy Ghost. Movie audiences, though, will doubtless see in it the hand of the man who directed “Braveheart.” On one level, Gibson, who has been working on the film for more than a year, perceives The Passion of the Christ as a heroic action story, and the principal quality he hoped to instill in it was the power of realism. “I wanted to bring you there,” he says, “and I wanted to be true to the Gospels. That has never been done.”


Click on the line to go to the top of the page.

[Home] [Articles] [FAQ] [Main Issues] [Anti-Semitism] [Roman Catholicism] [Mel Gibson] [New Testament] [Politics & The People of God] [Warrior Jesus] [Overview] [Analysis-Reviews]